Occupy Harvard? Students Protest Course Of Romney Advisor Gregory Mankiw

Harvard University students and demonstrators from Occupy Boston protested outside of Gregory Mankiw's economics course. (Adam Ragusea/WBUR)

Harvard University students and demonstrators from Occupy Boston protested outside of Gregory Mankiw's economics course. (Adam Ragusea/WBUR)

It’s a long hike from the mud-caked tents of Dewey Square to the polished wood and stained glass of Harvard University’s Memorial Hall, but on Tuesday, Occupy Boston came to campus.

And they brought their Occupy-style call-and-response.

“Oh my god, this is a lot of people,” organizer Rachel Sandalow-Ash said.
“Oh my god, this is a lot of people,” the group repeated.
“This is very exciting.”
“This is very exciting.”

About 50 students and Occupy supporters walked out of the introductory economics class taught by professor Gregory Mankiw, a conservative economist who serves as an advisor to presidential candidate Mitt Romney, and was Chairman of the Council of Economic Advisors under President George W. Bush.

“This course will influence Harvard graduates.”
“This course will influence Harvard graduates.”

“Harvard students have been complicit,”
“Harvard students have been complicit,”
“Have aided,”
“Have aided,”
“Many of the worst injustices in recent years.”
“Many of the worst injustices in recent years.”

“Harvard students will not do that anymore.”
“Harvard students will not do that anymore.”

The bulk of the protesters’ classmates stuck around to hear Mankiw’s lecture, which happened to be on the subject of income inequality — an irony the economist noted on his widely-read blog. “I am sorry the protesters will miss it,” he wrote.

Harvard freshmen and walkout organizers Sandalow-Ash and Gabriel Bayard said Mankiw teaches economics with a conservative bent.

“Professor Mankiw says that the minimum wage causes unemployment when empirical studies have proven this not to be true in many cases. Professor Mankiw says rent control causes racial discrimination,” Sandalow-Ash said.

“Mankiw associates equity in the economic system to efficiency, which definitely isn’t necessarily true,” Bayard said.

“He also does not talk at all about the 2008 collapse,” Sandalow-Ash said, to which Baynard added: “He mentions it, but he doesn’t mention his complicity in it.”

Mankiw declined to be interviewed on Radio Boston, though he told the Harvard Crimson that his class teaches “mainstream economics,” the goal of which, he said, “is to help people evaluate the inevitable tradeoffs that public policy entails.”

The students who walked-out proceeded to the Occupy Boston encampment across the river, where they brought winter-weather donations for the demonstrators.

  • Harvard C’15

    The counterprotest to this walkout was a lot bigger than this action. In fact, people started cheering and clapping for Mankiw, and the counterprotest walkin came in to applause too.

    • Beez

      Not suprising considering it is HARVARD.

    • http://socialismartnature.tumblr.com Socialism Art Nature

      That’s utterly false. Were you even there? The ‘counterprotest’ being referenced here consisted of a ‘walk-in’ of about 10 or so people maximum who marched into the class as about 50-75 people walked out.

    • http://twitter.com/aragusea Adam Ragusea

      Just wanted to mention that I was not allowed inside the classroom, and thus could not report on what happened inside, though I do believe I overheard some applause inside after the protesters walked out.

      • guest

        The Crimson video shows student support for Mankiw during his class.  How is it that one class, one professor, one college can be held responsible for all the issues with Wall Street and our economic issues?  A balanced view is always appreciated.  50-70 students walked out?  Several hundred stayed… to support or simply to learn, think, form their own viewpoint and perhaps change the world.

    • Kd

      And the protestors must have been feeling dumb standing outside of the lecture room while the real intellectual minds were getting their priceless benefit of education.

  • Pintus

    I thought the point of college courses was to learn to think and argue.  If you don’t agree with the professor’s point of view, isn’t it part of the educational process to question and challenge? 

    • http://twitter.com/aragusea Adam Ragusea

      Pintus, I asked the students we quoted in this story the same question. Their argument is that EC 10, Mankiw’s class, is introductory in nature, and thus should present an unbiased, mainstream view of economics, as opposed to a more advanced class, where the students would have better critical skills with which to contextualize a professor’s explicit or implicit biases. That said, Mankiw says EC 10 does present a mainstream view of economics. It’s an interesting question that would require more reporting to answer.

    • http://twitter.com/verita1776 J.

      I learned long ago that professors only like to hear their own point of view.  I went to college for the purpose of learning how to think, but that sort of education was not provided.

      • Tanny

        Obviously you went to a poor college :)

        • Nats_uglyman

          Obviously Tanny did not go to anny college.

  • AJS

    Mainstream economics is ideology. And it is fostered by powerful vested interests in the business community and in professional economics circles. The students have a perfectly legitimate right to attempt to assert a counter-hegemony

  • joanne

    It just shows how narrow-minded and intolerant to opposing
    views left wingers are.

  • Rorvig

    So I guess the students who walked out were admitting that they were too dumb to find out before signing up for the course that the words from this professor would offend their delicate leftist sensibilities?

  • spikethedog

    Is this what they will be telling their friends?

     “I was proud to have walked out of a lecture given by someone whose views I didn’t approve of.
    Just don’t ask me why I signed up for it in the first place because that would cause my giant Harvard brain to explode.”

  • Joan

    Reply to Joanne  Re: Right Wing Agenda at Harvard

    This  shows how the conservative agenda is being being peddled at Harvard and it must stop.
    It’s un- American and as Karl Marx so rightly  pointed out –capitalism without a conscience
    is a recipe for revolt….

    This is what’s happening today. People are saying “enough” and “no more”  Change the tax code and take out the loopholes and break up Wall Street monopolies who are considered “too big to fail” …Joan

  • Captain Spaulding

    These people are so stupid they have to talk in chant.

    But they’re the smartest amongst us – they are after all running our country.

    Should we be surprised by this coming from the state where Elizabeth Warren openly praises Marxism and will probably win her election?

    Now why don’t you pay your taxes and have a nice day. :)

    /sarc(????)

  • Ronny

    These degenerates don’t protest courses that espouse Communism or speak favorably of genocide. No, they protest any kernel of conservative thought. These people are the embodiment of the new evil.

  • Gttpboston

    We  all have to take responsablity for what a mess our world is in today, where is the LOVE?

Hosts Meghna Chakrabarti and Anthony Brooks introduce us to newsmakers, big thinkers and artists and bring us stories of relevance to Bostonians here and around the region. Live every weekday at 3.

  • Listen: Weekdays, 3 p.m. on 90.9 FM
  • Live Call-In: (800) 423-TALK
  • Listener Voicemail: (617) 353-1137
UNDERWRITING
Most Popular
This site is best viewed with: Firefox | Internet Explorer 9 | Chrome | Safari